Thanksgiving Menu
Pre-Orders for sweet treats offered by Red Lily Baking Submit pre-order by 11/23 @ 4pm by at the latest. Tax fees apply. Delivery on 11/26/25. Delivery fees apply: Starting at $7(fee based on distance of delivery) Pickup option available at Roast’d Coffee, 49 Claremont Ave, Montclair, NJ. Questions or inquires, call or text 973-433-5442, email redlilybaking@gmail.com www.redlilybaking.com
Cookies
Variety of cookies
Chocolate Chip Cookie (dozen)
Chocolate Chip Cookies – dozen - Soft rich chocolate chip cookies, with semisweet chocolate chips - Measure at 2.5 ounces each cookie Standard Dozen: cookies will be presented in a 8-inch cake box with tissue paper. Individually wrapped Dozen: Cookies individually wrapped, and placed in 8-inch cake box.
Standard Dozen
$30
Individually wrapped Dozen
$37
Tarts
Our desserts are made in house by our pastry chef; Limited Availability
Caramel Nut Tart (Thanksgiving item)
- Tart filled with caramel toasted walnuts, covered with a baked almond cream, and dusted lightly with powdered sugar. Wonderful addition to your holiday feast. - 9 inch tart, serves approx. 8-12 - contains walnuts, almonds, dairy
$50
Pies
Limited availability
Pumpkin Pie (Thanksgiving Item)
Pumpkin Pie – $45 (10 limited availability) - Smooth and creamy pumpkin pie. Warm spices like cinnamon and nutmeg to warm up the festivities! - 9 inch pie, serves 8-12 - Contains dairy
$45
Apple Pie (Thanksgiving Item)
Apple Pie – $40 (10 Limited availability) - Classic addition to holiday gatherings - 9 inch pie, serves 8-12
$40
