Best Sellers
Best sellers, available weekly!
Red Lily Best Sellers
Items that are staples in the Red Lily Baking rotation! Pre-orders available online. Orders must be placed by Sunday of each week. Pickup/ delivery available by Wednesday and Thursday. (delivery fees apply, min $7 pending delivery address)
Banana Bread Loaf
Our best seller! Moist Banana Bread with warm spices of vanilla, cinnamon and nutmeg. Nostalgia at its finest! Small- 6” x 2” Large- 8” x 2.5”
Small
$6
Large
$9.50
Walnuts
Walnuts
$2
Jalapeño Cheddar Scones
Jalapeño Cheddar Scones - standard loaf Spicy and cheesy tender jalapeño scones. Crowd favorite! Priced at $5 per scone, min order 8 scones
8 Scones
$40
16 Scones
$75
Banana Muffins
Our signature banana bread, in muffin form! Pre-order available by the dozen
$48
Walnuts
Walnuts
$2
Cookies
OG cookies, smaller weighing in at 2.5 oz/cookie
Chocolate Chip Cookie (dozen)
Chocolate Chip Cookies – dozen - Soft rich chocolate chip cookies, with semisweet chocolate chips - Measure at 2.5 ounces each cookie Standard Dozen: cookies will be presented in a 8-inch cake box with tissue paper. Individually wrapped Dozen: Cookies individually wrapped, and placed in 8-inch cake box.
Standard Dozen
$28
Individually wrapped Dozen
$30
Salted Chipless Cookie (dozen)
Salted Chipless Cookies – dozen - Soft rich "chocolate chip" cookies-- minus the chocolate chips, sprinkled with flakey sea salt - Measure at 2.5 ounces each cookie Standard Dozen: cookies will be presented in a 8-inch cake box with tissue paper. Individually wrapped Dozen: Cookies individually wrapped, and placed in 8-inch cake box.
Standard Dozen
$30
Individually wrapped Dozen
$32
Salted Pecan Chocolate Chip Cookie (dozen)
Salted Pecan Chocolate Chip Cookies - dozen - With chopped pecans, rich chocolate chips and Maldon flakey sea salt. Sweet and salty. - Measure at 2.5 ounces each cookie Standard Dozen: cookies will be presented in a 8-inch cake box with tissue paper. Individually wrapped Dozen: Cookies individually wrapped, and placed in 8-inch cake box.
Standard Dozen
$40
Individually wrapped Dozen
$42
White Chocolate Macadamia Cookie
White Chocolate Macadamia Cookies – dozen - Indulgent white chocolate macadamia nut cookies, Callebaut white chocolate - Measure at 2.5 ounces each cookie Standard Dozen: cookies will be presented in a 8-inch cake box with tissue paper. Individually wrapped Dozen: Cookies individually wrapped, and placed in 8-inch cake box.
Standard Dozen
$40
Individually wrapped Dozen
$42
Protein Banana Muffin
Healthy Protein Banana Muffin - plant based protein- Pea and hemp protein - healthy fats - avocado oil - organic bananas - not vegan (contains eggs) - no refined sugars - medjool dates - 5 g protein per muffin, for a light protein snack after a workout
Protein Banana Muffins
Healthy Protein Banana Muffin - plant based protein- Pea and hemp protein - healthy fats - avocado oil - organic bananas - not vegan (contains eggs) - no refined sugars - medjool dates - 5 g protein per muffin, for a light protein snack after a workout
Half Dozen (6)
$24
Standard Dozen
$45
Walnuts
Walnuts
$2
RLB Bakery Style Cookies
Soft baked bakery style cookies, measuring at 5 oz per cookie for a delicious nostalgic treat Now available at the River Vale Farmer's market, every other thursday
RLB Chocolate Chip Cookies
Classic Chocolate Chip cookie, weighs 5oz per cookie
Single serve
$5.50
Standard Dozen
$60
RLB Salted Pecan Choc Chip Cookies
An elevated spin on chocolate chip cookies, with toasted pecans and finishing sea salt for a sweet and salty treat! weighs 5 oz/cookie
Single serve
$5.50
Standard Dozen
$60
RLB White Chocolate Rainbow Sprinkle Cookies
Think funfetti in a cookie-- rainbow sprinkles and white chocolate chips. It's gotta be someone's birthday, why not celebrate! weighs 5 oz/cookie
Single serve
$5.50
Standard Dozen
$60
RLB S'mores Cookies
Summer nights by the campfire... how about a s'mores from the comfort of your own home... Classic pairing of graham crackers, marshmallows and milk chocolate. weighs 5 oz/cookie
Single serve
$5.50
Standard Dozen
$60